Big Meet 5
29 April 2016, London
With the demise of national funding for design review from 2013, the landscape for design review has rapidly and fundamentally changed. From a public
About Big Meet 5: National conference on Design Review
To help clarify the situation, or at least to begin the process of more openly and systematically debating it, in April the Place Alliance devoted BIG MEET 5 to a “National conference on design review”. We took a wide range of contributions from experts who had been or currently are involved in design review from a wide range of perspectives and from all the nations of the UK and beyond.
Multi award winning Malings development in the Ouseburn Valley has undergone two Design Review sessions prior to planning permission © Ash Sakula Architects
Different aspects and challenges of design review were discussed in a lively panel discussion chaired by Leanne Tritton and featuring Dr Richard Simmons, Victor Callister, David Tittle Mary Laheen, Andrew Forth and Nigel Longstaff.
© Healthy streets for London, TfL.
Q & A session
Participants discussed questions relating to accreditation of Design Review Panels, the problem of panels not being public; and also touched upon the ways of bringing community engagement and DR together.
© Design Council
Chaired by Ben Van Bruggen the afternoon session addressed the challenge of offering quality service. Is design review the right process for public engagement?
Or should it be part of a suite? Placemaking is part of what local planning authorities do, cannot be devolved wholly to their consultants. How can the right balance be struck between advisers and decision-makers?
Featured Talks & Speakers
Place Alliance is thankful to all Big Meet speakers for being so generous with their time.
We really appreciate the involvement and we are grateful for the time and effort speakers took to share their thoughts and experiences with all our Supporters.
We hope that they enjoyed contributing and have gained further insight from the experience.
Policy & Public Affairs Manager at RIBA.
Andrew Forth began by quoting the Ministerial foreword to NPPF: “Our standards of design
could be so much higher…confidence in development itself has been eroded by the too frequent experience of mediocrity”. Design review was one way of addressing the problem.
The creative role of design review was illustrated by a case study from Newcastle, where a brownfield site in the Ouseburn Valley had been redeveloped for housing. The scheme had been reviewed at outline and detailed stages.
The review had challenged and encouraged the design team, by examining the practicalities of the scheme and not just the aesthetics. The built scheme had subsequently won a clutch of housing and architecture awards.
Dr Richard Simmons
Visiting lecturer at the Bartlett School of Planning and the University of Greenwich School of the Built Environment, former Chief Executive of the Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE).
Richard Simmons reflected on his experience as Chief Executive at Cabe and on the changes that have taken place since 2012. In 2015 Simmons investigated all the extant major panels in England, looking at their operations and the guidance they worked to. All aimed to be constructive critical friends. Meetings are now longer and more all day, workshop-style sessions are held. Not all reports are shared with the local planning authority.
On the other hand, there is now greater quality between the main panels, and Design Council
CABE is no longer seen as the top tier or parent panel. Collaborative working and site visits are helping to support a greater local focus and knowledge.
Simmons also noted a growing international dimension, with successful panels in South Australia, Boston (Institute for Human Centred Design, specialising in accessibility) and Tokyo.
General Manager and Design Champion of the Auckland Design Office at Auckland Council, former CEO of Urban Design London and a Senior Urban Designer at the London Borough of Tower Hamlets. @AklDesignChamp
In a specially prepared short film, Ludo Campbell Reid and his colleagues outlined the work of the Auckland Urban Design Panel, set up in 2003. The Panel is playing a key role in the transformation of the city – helping it to be “beautifully reshaped”, in the words of City Mayor Len Brown.
The Panel is supported by the Property Council of New Zealand in partnership with Auckland Council and reviews both public and private sector projects, including public realm schemes. There are also a range of sub-panels on themes like housing.